Some Determinations on the Use of Nine Formals in Enemy Qualifications

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.61620/tfa.67

Keywords:

nine enemies, number, formal, Nine Oghuz, Thutmose III stele

Abstract

While numbers play a very important role in the human mind's understanding of the observable universe, they also determine the patterns of the metaphorical context as formal elements.  Within the specific logic of reality, different contexts may sometimes tend to overlap. One particular example of the tendency of the physical universe and the metaphorical context to overlap within their logic of reality concerns the use of the nine formalisms in some common characterizations. In this article, which discusses whether the number nine has a tendency to become stereotyped - albeit limited - as an adjective characterizing the enemy in various aspects in some literary/folkloric and historical texts, some findings have been made based on sample texts. In cases where the number nine comes to the fore with its feature of expressing an indefinite multiplicity, it is seen that the function of this formal in enemy qualifications is more noticeable. It is almost impossible to find a more appropriate number than nine to express the enemy numerically, with its various qualities as a foreign, other or a phenomenon that is difficult to define. As a matter of fact, the widespread use of this formalism in descriptions related to Erlik, who is depicted as the enemy of divine unity, reveals a stereotype in the collective subconscious. The coincidental similarity between the nine enemy representations in Ancient Egypt and the Nine Oghuzs in the Gokturk Inscriptions, and the ninth move principle that Emir Timur tried to defeat the enemy are extremely interesting historical propositions. The nine enemy descriptions that we encounter in various narratives, especially in the Book of Dedem Korkut, hint at a hidden tendency towards stereotyping in folk narratives. In the examples identified, it is quite functional that the highest single-digit number, nine, was preferred to describe the enemy, which is the symbol of uncertainty and chaos. The examples of the nine enemy phenomena in literary/folkloric and historical texts identified in this article can be increased with comprehensive studies.

References

Alkaya, E. (2021). Dede Korkut kitabında geçen doksan tümen ifadesi üzerine. IX. Uluslararası Türk Dili Kurultayı: Bilge Tonyukuk anısına (Ankara: 26-30 Eylül 2021) I. Cilt. Türk Dil Kurumu, 191-207.

Bayat, F. (2017). Kadim Türklerin mitolojik hikâyeleri. Ötüken.

Budge, E. A. W. (2010). Antik Mısır edebiyatı – Yazınsal metinler. (çev. S. Albayrak). İlya.

Çoruhlu, Y. (2000). Türk mitolojisinin anahatları. Kabalcı.

Ergin, M. (2008). Dede Korkut kitabı I - Giriş, metin, faksimile-. 6. bs., Türk Dil Kurumu.

Ergin, M. (2009). Orhun abideleri. İstanbul: Boğaziçi.

Erkoç, H. İ. vd. (2019). Dokuz Oğuzlar ve Oğuzlar üzerine araştırmalar. (ed.T. O. Özgün,). Gece Akademi.

Hamilton, J. (1997). Tokuz-Oğuz ve on Uygur. (çev. Y. Koç, İ. Birkan,) Türk Dilleri Araştırmaları, 7, 187-232.

Komisyon (1996). Bölge ağızlarında atasözleri ve deyimler. Türk Dil Kurumu.

Laszslo, F. (1950). Dokuz Oğuzlar ve Gök Türkler. (çev. H. Eren) Belleten, 53 (14), 37-44.

Ögel, B. (2010). Türk mitolojisi - I. Cilt. 5 bs., Türk Tarih Kurumu.

Sahîbkıran Emir Timur Muhammed Tarağay Bahadıroğlu (2010). Timur’un günlüğü -Tüzükât-ı Timur-. 2. bs, (K. Şakirov, A. Aslan, Haz.). İnsan.

Schimmel, A. (1998). Sayıların gizemi. (çev. M. Küpüşoğlu). Kabalcı.

Sümer, F. (1997). Tokuz Oğuzlar. M.E.B. İslâm ansiklopedisi, Millî Eğitim Bakanlığı, 420-427.

Tait, J. (2003). Never had the like occurred: Egypt’s View of its Past. UCL.

Waziry, A. (2019). An unpublished pedestal of Ramses II from Antinoopolis with reference to the nine bows. Journal of Ancient History and Archaeology, 6, 14-29.

Published

2025-06-30

How to Cite

Daşdemir, Özkan. (2025). Some Determinations on the Use of Nine Formals in Enemy Qualifications. Türk Folklor Araştırmaları, (371), 226–235. https://doi.org/10.61620/tfa.67

Issue

Section

Articles